Dead man walking matthew poncelet essay

Murderers can still be made to pay for their crimes by placing them in jail for life without any chance of parole. No one should have to die to help someone keep their job. There are four rational conclusions one can make regarding general, or systemic, deterrence.

At the end Matthew hopes that the father of Walter the victim can forgive him and accept that he knows what he was wrong and should be punished for it, but not punished to death. The most relevant aggravated crime is robbery with injury, wherein blacks are 21 times more likely to be involved in such crimes as are whites.

Although these studies have been produced by respected social scientists, there are also studies which show no general deterrent effect. Many of these feelings are because of his understanding of human life, as his life nears the end.

Additionally, some countries, such as Saudi Arabia, have swift and sure executions and very low violent crime rates.

The families of the victims wanted to execute Poncelet to gain simple justice for their unbearable loss. Their punishment could not be increased because there is no death penalty in those states. The killer was arrested and convicted, then served 14 years in prison.

The parents of the victim "Hope" were filled with revenge because of what Matthew did, not why he did it. The movie Dead Man Walking looks at all these complex issues surrounding capital punishment and forces its audience to take sides.

Earl Delacroix was the father of the teenage boy who was murdered by Matthew Poncelet. Therefore, if a swift and sure death penalty was universally applied to our worst criminals, it is logically conclusive that the death penalty would be a significant deterrent and that many innocent lives would be saved.

IF overall murder statistics are consistent, within this crime category, as McCleskey et al suggests, then there is a While the opinions and reactions of people to Dead Man Walking may vary, the one constant is that people will have a reaction. For instance, he is not given another trial when his new lawyer explains to a judge that Poncelet did not receive a proper defense at his original trial.

He harbored a lot of hatred and sadness because of the slaying.

Therefore, even though it may be statistically elusive, the general deterrent effect is proven by individual deterrence. Not in our name. In each instance, she was uncertain and apprehensive. The remaining 11 cases represent 0. The family, unlike Mr.

Apparent disparities in sentencing are an inevitable part of our criminal justice system.

Dead Man Walking - Sample Opinion Essay

Blacks have suffered some years of slavery and blatantly racist criminal justice practices. Further denouncing the brutalization effect is the fact that many respected studies show that executions do produce an individual and a general deterrent effect.

If killing people is immoral and wrong, then justice is not served by killing murderers in prison death chambers. I believe that once a person has convicted a serious murder they should be put to death, no questions asked; if not they could get out of jail and commit the same types of crimes numerous times again.

Should we balance the scales of justice and execute equally the killers of blacks and whites. This too makes the death penalty seem unjust. Could it be that whites are, overwhelmingly, the victims in death row cases because whites are, overwhelmingly, the victims in capital crimes.

She approached each with a hopeful attitude, trying to understand them while also trying to give them peace. When such an event takes place we want revenge.

Her relationship with the convict, Matthew Poncelet, was on two levels. It took place at midnight Jones ed.

Dead Man Walking Paper

However, such studies are inconclusive because there are also studies that find no such effect - not surprising, as the U. She believes that there is good in all man and that every person deserves respect. This is what was needed for Matthew, as a person. The film "Dead Man Walking" raised an important ethical issue about whether a convicted criminal on death row should be allowed to have a spiritual advisor.

I think the moral issue of the movie revolves around whether a spiritual advisor, such as a nun, should lend comfort or support to a death row inmate, such as Matthew Poncelet.4/4(1).

Analysis of Dead Man Walking, Free Study Guides and book notes including comprehensive chapter analysis, complete summary analysis, author biography information, character profiles, theme analysis, metaphor analysis, and top ten quotes on classic literature. Dead Man Walking is a film from the early nineties.

It takes place in New Orleans in the United States. Helen, on of the main characters of the film, lives in New Orleans, in one of the black neighbourhoods. Dead Man Walking is a film based on the book of the same name - it recounts the experiences of Sister Helen Prejean, a nun from Louisiana.

It focuses on her relationship with Matthew Poncelet, a convicted murderer on Death Row. The play ‘Dead Man Walking’ is about redemption. In the play, a story is told of a man put on a death row. The main characters in the play are, Matthew Poncelet (Seann Penn), who gains the company and friendship of a nun, Sister Helen Prejeon (Susan Sarandon).

It is the second book after her famous novel “Dead Man Walking”, that was adapted into a hit film by the same name, telling the story of Sister Prejean as she establishes a special relationship with Matthew Poncelet, an inmate on death row.

Dead man walking matthew poncelet essay
Rated 0/5 based on 70 review
mrbanksbluevale [licensed for non-commercial use only] / Dead Man Walking - Sample Opinion Essay